Maddie’s Musings: Decking the Halls or Decking the Turkey?

Christmas or Thanksgiving? The age-old question.
Madison Long/Editor in Chief

Madison Long

Editor in Chief

A shrill voice breaks through the serene fall scene – “It’s timeeeeeeee.”

The minute Halloween decor hits the shelves, a backroom storage shelf somewhere is prepped and stocked with an abundance of Christmas presents, sweaters and lights.

And despite the stores waiting until Oct. 20, the hardcore holiday-heads are not waiting for Mariah Carey to thaw out.

For many, Christmastime starts as soon as the air chills.

A season surrounded by kindness, generosity and colorful vibes certainly keeps the winter blues away. The nostalgia of waiting for presents or eating as a family helps homesick students bide their lonely meantime before the flight home.

However, others – myself included – wait until after Thanksgiving to start the giving season.

Some might feel the growing financial and emotional burden of buying gifts – think of “The Gift of the Magi.” There’s also potential family tensions to think about, tensions that stay unresolved and avoided until Christmas dinner. Along that same taut line, there’s also empty chairs when the holidays roll around in the wake of a family loss.

Despite internet discourse, there is no right or wrong – each family has to decide what they want. 

My family decorates for winter and Christmas around the time I come home for Thanksgiving. We avoid the present drama by shopping all-year round.

My cousin down the street decorates mid-October because the feeling of Christmas songs and lights brings her more joy than anything else. She makes lists and organizes plans for her Christmas gifts to efficiently shop.

For the Christmas-in-July group, I can see the appeal. I find myself wanting to listen to Halloween music or watch themed movies all year round. The vibe of Halloween ruminates in my soul.

However, I can also see the opposing side. Celebrating the holidays too early can quickly disregard the season we’re in: the falling of the leaves and the last warm brush of sun.

Most importantly through this debate, I think, is the meaning behind all and any holidays: getting together as a family. With just one more excuse to meet, chat and bask in everyone’s weirdness, the holiday seasons (turkey and tree alike) are about moving your best foot forward. Even without family, the idea of harmony and connecting with others still permeates the atmosphere.

The holidays aren’t made to be a place of huge criticism – don’t make your joy be someone else’s required participation.

My cousin and I work hard to meet in the middle – enjoy the basted ham and creamy mashed potatoes on Thursday and start the Christmas movie marathon on Friday. Christmas music blasts in her car as much as she wants, so long as I can put non-holiday music on the queue. She decorates as early and as extravagantly as possible, but she still holds off until after Día de los Muertos for her roommate. 

Personally, I think that holidays should be celebrated however and whenever. Putting up the Christmas tree a little early to bring happiness to one person doesn’t diminish the turkey’s taste. And wanting to celebrate Thanksgiving and the changing of seasons before jumping into the craze of present-shopping isn’t a bad thing.

And while I may make snide comments about how early we have to decorate, my cousin’s stubbornness constantly reminds me why I love her and how holidays can bring us together.

Madison Long

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

ISU’s Institute of Rural Health lands nearly $500K federal grant to help pregnant women in Southeast Idaho buy produce

Thu Nov 19 , 2026
Idaho State University’s Institute of Rural Health has received $499,465 in federal funding to launch a program that will help low-income pregnant women in Southeast Idaho put more fruits and vegetables on the table.

You May Like

please add Widgets in Off Canvas Sidebar