Mocktail Monday: Eggless-Nog and Soft Lemonade

Rachel Marwedel

Website Manager

Each Monday, I gather my roommates and taste-test two mocktails. Here’s how this week’s went: 

Eggless-Nog

Is it really eggnog if you remove the eggs?

6 cups non-dairy milk 

1 ½ cups coconut milk

1 ½ tsp non-alcoholic vanilla extract

¼ tsp nutmeg

⅛ tsp cinnamon

6 pitted dates

(optional) ground nutmeg or cinnamon for garnish

Soak dates for 10 minutes. Blend the dates well, then add the rest of the ingredients and blend again. Serve with a sprinkle of nutmeg or cinnamon. 

This recipe comes from Drinking for Two by Diana Licalzi Maldonado and Kerry Benson. Before you start, do know – I did absolutely zero measuring in this, and totally guesstimated. I began with soaking my dates. This was my first time using dates, so after the initial thought of “Soak??? Like a bath??? Am I… bathing fruit now?” I let them rest in some water for 20 minutes and then blended. After blending, I added the spices, coconut milk, vanilla extract, and a special blend of non-dairy milks. Why a blend? Well, one summer, I worked at a coffee shop where I had too much time and not enough supervision. As a result, I tried, tried again, and tested every possible combination of non-dairy milks. My conclusions? Half soy and half oat is the optimal mix. I strained the end result, and sprinkled a bit of nutmeg on top.

I’m actually allergic to large quantities of eggs, so I can’t have regular eggnog. Upon first taste, I thought: “This is it! Ambrosia from heaven, finally mine!” But my very kind, not-allergic-to-eggs roommates told me it just tasted like oat milk with some nutmeg. Oh well. 

Rating: 1.5/3

Soft Lemonade

Isn’t soft lemonade just…lemonade…?

¾ cup lemon juice

3 cups coconut water

3 tbsp light agave nectar

3 cups seltzer

(optional) lemon slices for garnish

Mix the lemon juice, coconut water, and agave nectar in a pitcher. Stir well. Top with seltzer; stir. Serve over ice in highball glasses. Garnish with lemon slices.

This recipe also comes from Drinking for Two, and I ended up cutting this recipe by a third. It was a pretty simple process: mix, add the seltzer, mix again, then add some ice. I found my agave nectar by the bulk honey in Winco, and my highball glasses nowhere, because I didn’t use highball glasses. 

Look. I’ve had Chick-fil-a lemonade, I’ve had side-of-the-road some kid’s summer business lemonade. I’ve had strawberry lemonade, blueberry lemonade, even lavender lemonade. And I’ve never liked a single one – until this drink came along. It’s soft, subtle, sweet, and all-around a delight compared to the sickening sugary tones of the $1 cup of lemonade you just purchased from a gap-toothed child’s stand on a sweltering August day. So for any kids reading this with dreams of running their very own lemonade stand… take notes!

Rating: 2/3 (but on the lemonade scale, it’s a 3/3)

Photos by Rachel Marwedel.

Rachel Marwedel

Next Post

FROM CAMPUS TO THE STREETS: STUDENTS JOIN THE ‘NO KINGS’ CALL

Tue Oct 28 , 2025
[Pocatello, ID] Students and community members gathered outside the Bannock County Courthouse on Oct. 18 to join the nationwide ‘No Kings’ movement, calling for democratic accountability and equality through peaceful protest and student activism.

You May Like

please add Widgets in Off Canvas Sidebar