Braxton Gregory
Sports Editor
POCATELLO, Idaho — James “Jim” Koetter, a towering figure in Pocatello athletics and a former Idaho State head coach, passed away Feb. 18. He was 87.
Over more than four decades, Koetter shaped the city’s sports landscape, mentoring generations of athletes and coaches while building some of the most successful programs in local history. But his influence extended far beyond wins and championships – he was a mentor, a leader, and a guiding presence in the lives of countless students, athletes, and community members.
Koetter arrived at Idaho State in 1958 as a two-sport athlete, playing receiver for Babe Caccia’s football team and running track under Dubby Holt. His achievements earned him an induction into the Idaho State Sports Hall of Fame in 1985, but his greatest legacy came from the sidelines.
In 1965, he became Highland High School’s head football coach, immediately establishing a culture of excellence.
Over 15 seasons, he led the Rams to a 102-49-2 record, including back-to-back state titles in 1972 and 1973. His coaching philosophy, summarized by the mantra “Right Attitude Means Success,” became the foundation of Highland athletics and continues to shape the program today.
His impact wasn’t limited to football. He spent 11 years as an assistant basketball coach, helping Highland qualify for the state tournament every season, and played a key role in developing state champions in track.
Koetter’s ability to inspire young athletes extended beyond the field. He was a mentor and a father figure to many, offering guidance that shaped both careers and lives.
“I owe my teaching and coaching career to this man,” Highland coach Gino Mariani said. “He touched so many in Pocatello. A father figure, a coach, a teacher.”
In 1979, Koetter returned to Idaho State as an assistant under Dave Kragthorpe, helping lead the Bengals to the 1981 NCAA Division I-AA national championship.
He was named head coach in 1983 and, in his five seasons, led Idaho State to its last FCS playoff appearance. He was also the last Bengals coach to defeat both Idaho and Boise State in the same season.
Koetter continued shaping lives at Pocatello High School, where he took over a struggling football program in 1988. In just his second season, he led the Indians to a state championship.
His teams won additional titles in 1990, 1992, and 1994, cementing one of the most dominant runs in Idaho high school football history. He also coached the girls’ basketball team alongside his son, Brent, guiding the team to four consecutive state runner-up finishes.
His influence stretched beyond X’s and O’s. He had an innate ability to connect with young people, instilling confidence and discipline in athletes and non-athletes alike.
Ray Cardona, who first met Koetter in Aberdeen, recalled how he introduced him to the sport.
“So sad,” Cardona said. “First met him when he coached Aberdeen High School football. We lived across the street, and we would help shag balls and whatever he wanted us to do. He let us use helmets and pads and told us to practice. Got us all interested in football. He will be missed.”
Even after retiring from coaching in 2000, Koetter remained deeply involved in Pocatello athletics, assisting Brent at Highland and continuing to mentor young athletes. His presence on the sidelines, in locker rooms, and throughout the community became a defining part of Pocatello sports.
Koetter’s legacy is measured not just in victories but in the thousands of lives he touched. He was more than a coach – he was a leader, a mentor, a father, and a lasting symbol of dedication to both the game and the people of Pocatello.
For those wishing to learn more or share a memory, visit Wilks Funeral Home’s website at https://www.wilksfuneralhomes.com/obituaries/james-koetter and view “Celebrating the Life of James ‘Jim’ Koetter,” where a memory book is available to read and contribute to.